Julianne considers her Amish life boring. She's also resigned herself to being a spinster for the rest of her life. There are no men in town she's even remotely interested in even though every single man is pining for her attention.

This all changes when a handsome stranger moves into the Amish town. His name is James and he is a former baseball star whose fame and fortune have fizzled out. He comes to the Amish town to get away from all the media but he doesn't count on the Amish people being quite nosy...Particularly when a romance between he and Julianne blossoms.

But when an incident from his past life becomes newsworthy, their budding love is put to the test immediately. Can it withstand all of the gossip from the town and the media?