To honor the town's first responders, the Myerton Business Owner's Association has decided to sponsor an all-expense paid trip to a Jamaican resort. Dan Conway is the lucky winner, and with Father Tom, Helen, and others taking charge of the Conway children, he and Miriam jet off to the Caribbean for one last vacation before their sixth child arrives.

No sooner have the couple left than the body of a multilevel marketing representative is found in the backyard of the home of the host of the weekly meeting of Rosary Mom's. Fortunately, Helen is on the scene, attending the meeting with Father Tom and the Conway children in tow.

Unfortunately, Catherine Conway helps Helen find the body, bringing her the unfortunate woman's red shoe.

With the help of Father Tom, Junior Detective Conway, and two bored moms, Helen investigates who in the woman's life would have wanted her dead . . . and why.