Jessica Moore loves her family but is certain she'll never find someone to marry. One morning, she walks into town and sees the same advertisement she's been seeing for years about a woman who would arrange a mail-order bride marriage for her.

She decides to take a chance and see Elizabeth Tandy, who has a husband picked out for her in a matter of moments. The idea of marrying a man with four small children is very appealing, and she answers his ad immediately.

George Fleming found the love of his life while he was still going to the one-room schoolhouse he'd attended for years. He married that love and planned to live forever with her. He knows he'll never love another woman when she dies unexpectedly in childbirth, but he needs a mother for his children.

When Jessica arrives, she expects to be greeted with open arms, but the truth is something different. Will George ever find it in himself to love his sweet bride? Or will she spend the rest of her life being rejected by a man who can't get over the loss of his first love?