Molly's days at Banbury Village, a living history museum, are filled with variety and occasional surprises, such as when Cecelia, the goat, escapes and it's Molly's job to capture her; or when Molly has to singlehandedly plan the annual Valentine's Ball fundraiser. But for the most part, her life is peaceful. Some might say boring. Things might have been very different had the great love of her life, Gage, not left town after graduation, never to return. She wonders if he might have stayed had she told him how she felt about him all those years ago, but she knows she can't change the past. Then one day, Gage returns.

Gage knew he couldn't stay in Banbury knowing Molly was with Brent, and when he left town he told himself it was for the best. But fifteen years later, he knows he has to return and tell Molly he's been in love with her since the first time he saw her. When his eyes meet hers across a crowded room, he knows he's come home. All he needs to do is convince her they belong together.