Hazel Thompson is found dead in Little Valley's now-famous Amish Inn, and there's a long list of suspects with plenty of motive.

Much to the dismay of the Amish community, the sheriff's prime suspect is Eva Zook, the owner of the new Amish bakery. In almost Deja vu fashion, the twin sisters, Anna and Beth, find themselves once again faced with clearing their family's name, but things are even more complicated than before since the murder weapon has Eva's prints all over it.