McKenzie Noble's first business trip for her first real, post-college job takes her to the picturesque Christmas town of Amesbury, Montana. Both awed and aware of how surreal the festive town is, McKenzie wanders Main Street to take it all in. As if Main Street lit up with Christmas lights and carols of the season playing around town aren't enough to make her feel like she's landed in a Christmas movie, she can't believe her luck when the good-looking guy at Caffeinated Bliss starts a conversation with her. Duran Carey is a proud Amesbury local who loves his family, the community, and Christmas. He's never questioned returning to Amesbury after college armed with a business degree; he's never looked beyond helping his dad with the family store. That is until he meets the pretty blonde who's only in town for a few days.

Duran is happy to show McKenzie around Amesbury. Before long, the two develop an easy friendship that they both know could lead to more. But McKenzie's days in Amesbury are numbered, and Duran's heart has always belonged there.

With time running out, and Duran's parents away on vacation, McKenzie invites Duran to come home with her and share her Christmas. Will Duran take the leap and leave Amesbury to celebrate somewhere new, or will McKenzie go home sad and alone?