Life looks promising for Jacob, his ranch is thriving, he's in love with a wonderful woman and planning his wedding. When tragedy strikes and his fiancee flees from town under the cover of darkness his world comes crashing down. With no word from the woman he loves, Jacob has no choice but to move on with his life without her. Swearing off women forever he is not prepared for the delight the new young teacher brings to his life. As the pair plan their wedding his old fiancee arrives back in town expecting to pick up where they left off. Jacob finds himself engaged to two women who adore him. With their worlds in turmoil both young women vow to win Jacob's heart in very different ways. A heart-wrenching choice lays before him. Will he choose his first love or the spunky young school teacher?