Murders, Mysteries, and Misdemeanors in New York

New York’s criminal history is well documented, but some stories remain neglected. Others are almost entirely forgotten. William Kemmler, the first convict ever to sit in the electric chair, remains a familiar name. So does Chester Gillette, immortalized in Theodore Dreiser’s An American Tragedy. The incredible tale of Iron Mike Malloy is part of New York legend. Others, no less important, are overlooked.
Examples include Martha Place, the first woman in the electric chair; Paper Box Kid, Oreste Shillitoni, who shot his way out of Sing Sing Prison’s notorious Death House; Doctor Robert Buchanan, who made an important contribution to forensic science; Carlyle Harris, a household name in the 1890s who rarely draws attention today; and Eddie Lee Mays, New York’s 695th (and last) execution.
Crime writer Robert Walsh takes you on a journey through a rogues’ gallery of some of New York’s most notable crimes and criminals. Alongside them are some forgotten felons, whose stories, though less memorialized, are as fascinating as any.