As the owner of Heavenly Treasures, the local gift shop, Claire is busier than ever helping her customers find the perfect gift for the special people on their shopping list. Then word comes that Ruth and Samuel Yoder are being questioned in the death of an elderly Amish couple, found murdered after the newlyweds were seen leaving the victims’ farm. Ruth seeks Claire’s help in convincing the police that she and Samuel are innocent. But then Claire comes across a cryptic note tucked inside the wedding gift the victims had given the newlyweds. Can Claire get to the bottom of things in time to ensure a merry Christmas for all?