In the spring of 1939 as war clouds appear on the horizon, a young British Vicar on summer assignment to a church in a small town on the Connecticut shore introduces handsome Jewish, anti-war, recent Yale graduate Peter Stone who owns his own seaplane to stunning blonde, Protestant, co-ed Suzanne Taylor in a park across from his church. The son and daughter of rival New York banking families, both Peter and Suzanne immediately feel they have known the other before.

What begins as a simple summer romance soon turns into something far greater, far beyond their control, and far deeper then anything they could have ever imagined. As their passion becomes almost overpowering, a dark fear envelopes Suzanne who feels that something once happened before with Peter. Her fear that something once happened before with Peter forms the core of The Vicar’s Story setting in motion the terrible quest she and Peter must follow as they enter the eye of the storm.

Through loss, discovery, and resolution, they realize they have loved the other in two previous lives - with each life ending in an identical tragedy. Through previous life regressions, they realize they have been repeating those lives, enabling them to finally release the karma they have carried for centuries, allowing them to achieve the union they have been denied for a millennium.