Gabriel is gay and has a new crush on a boy he thinks is way out of his league. Jeffry is confident, but sweet and kind to those close to him. He's openly gay, unlike Gabriel who has only ever told his best friend, Mason, about his secret. Mason is straight, but has never been very good friends with anyone unless they're either gay or bi. She doesn't like most straight people. Her only exception is a boy she hasn't seen in two years, but still loves even if no one but Gabriel knows it. Alana is Gabriel's non-binary sister. They don't tend to like anyone, but when they have to get a job or be stuck in after school activities, they meet Theodora. Theodora is pan and not exactly the most innocent girl in town. She likes to get into trouble, but mostly because it's a good escape from her life. Her boyfriend is another good way out, but he's a jerk and even she knows it. Gabriel, Jeffry, Mason, Alana, and Theodora all want their own version of a happy ending, but none of them are quite sure how to get it.