Romanticism, Nationalism and the Revolt Against Theory

Why has Anglo-American culture for so long regarded theory with intense suspicion? In this important contribution to the history of critical theory, David Simpson argues that a nationalist myth underlies contemporary attacks on theory. Theory’s antagonists, Simpson shows, invoke the same criteria of common sense and national solidarity as did the British intellectuals who rebelled against theory and method during the French Revolution. Simpson demonstrates the close association between theory and method and shows that by the mid-eighteenth century, method had acquired distinctly subversive associations in England. Attributed increasingly to the French and the Germans, method paradoxically evoked images both of inhuman rationality and unbridled sentimentality; in either incarnation, it was seen as a threat to what was claimed to be authentically British. Simpson develops these paradigms in relation to feminism, the gendering of Anglo-American culture, and the emergence of literature and literary criticism as antitheoretical discourses. He then looks at the Romantic poets’ response to this confining ideology of the cultural role of literature. Finally, Simpson considers postmodern theory’s claims for the radical energy of nonrational or antirationalist positions. This is an essential book not only for students of the Romantic period and intellectual historians concerned with the idea of method, but for anyone interested in the historical background of today’s debates over the excesses and possibilities of theory.