Amelia is a young Amish woman who had pined after Michael ever since they were young teens. But as they grew older, he fell in love with someone else and Amelia was left heartbroken...until his girlfriend inexplicably left the community. Michael becomes distraught and in his frayed emotional state, pursues Amelia and asks for her hand in marriage. But his girlfriend returns shortly after, throwing Amelia's long held hopes into despair once again. Whom will Michael choose?