When Jacob Morley is a rarity...a male Amish teacher...and he cannot help but fall for the good looks of the mother of one of his students. He surreptitiously asks questions about her and comes to realize she is widowed but has her romantic eye on another man. Following some ungodly dating advice, Jacob begins to date another woman in the hopes of making the widower jealous and finally notice him. But will this wind up leaving everyone involved confused and hurt?