An old friendship shifting to a new romance. An ex-boyfriend extending an invitation. An urban legend in the flesh.

Critter Catchers and amateur monster hunters Cody and Demetrius are building their friendship into something hotter and deeper. Both are way out of their comfort zones, but willing to work at things. It will just take a little time until Cody feels comfortable "coming out" to their friends, family, and the rest of Parson's Hollow. Demetrius is trying to be patient and understanding about Cody's position, and focuses on their business. Or, rather, the lack thereof.

When Demetrius's ex, Oliver Berridge, invites him to come to Pinesville, New Jersey for a case that might be right up their alley, Demetrius is intrigued. Sensing not just physical but romantic danger as well, Cody makes certain to accompany Demmy on the trip.

Things in Pinesville are soon complicated by a competing animal control company and a group of monster trackers from a low-budget TV show. As the case intensifies, tempers flare and loyalties are tested, finally forcing Demmy and Cody to decide if they're willing to save their business, their friendship, or their romance.