Can one man's love win a fragile woman's heart?

After Amaya Alvarado lost her fiance to a senseless tragedy, she vows never to love again. Two years later, at her grandmother's request, she travels to Poplar Springs to assist with the mercantile and help care for her ailing grandfather. During a stagecoach accident and a confrontation with nefarious outlaws, she crosses paths with a man named Silas McFadden who rescues her and the other passengers. A bond between them soon forms.

Silas is not the man he once was. After a stint on the wrong side of the law, he's now a respectable rancher in Poplar Springs, Wyoming. After becoming a man of faith, he determines to live his life for the One who gave him a second chance. He just never imagined that second chance might include Amaya. Now all he has to do is ensure his past doesn't return and destroy his and Amaya's fragile relationship.

Amaya's and Silas's friendship soon grows, and she begins to trust him with everything but her heart. Can she push her growing feelings for him aside? After all, isn't it betraying her fiance to care for another man the way she has grown to care for Silas?

When the past comes back to haunt him and revenge is sought, can Silas protect the woman he has come to love?