Jesus’ best-known mandate–after perhaps the mandate to love God and neighbor–was given at the Last Supper just before his death: Do this in memory of me. Indeed, a case can be made that to do this is the source and summit of the way Christians carry out Jesus’ love-mandate. Of course, Christians have debated what it means to do this, and these debates have all too often led to divisions within and between them–debates over leavened and unleavened bread, reception of the cup, real presence and sacrifice, open or closed communion, this Supper and the hunger of the world. These divisions seem to fly in the face of Jesus’ mandate, causing some to wonder whether this is really the Lord’s Supper we celebrate (compare 1 Corinthians 11). Everything turns on just what it means to do this. The purpose of the Center for Catholic and Evangelical Theology’s 2012 conference was to address at least some of the many aspects of this question–to address them together, as Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox pastors and theologians, and all participants in the Supper.