Media Sociology and Journalism is a dialogue on contemporary society as defined through news media, politics, and contemporary sociological theory. The tenacity of deeply opposing truth claims in politics and in journalism exposes the current fragility of democracy as a type of society and regime of power. Debates are reviewed on competing explanations of post-truth attitudes, the rise of populism, fake news, conspiracy theories, neoliberalism, nihilism, white nationalism, and the flights from and too democracy. Focus is on the tenacity of deeply opposing truth claims where each side takes the other’s claim to be an existential threat. A dialogical critique of divisions in news media, politics, and contemporary sociological theory provides an alternative way forward as right populism, fake news, and post-truth attitudes render democracy fragile. It is argued that professional journalism also contributes to this fragility when it reports or opines on the most vulnerable subjects in society but does not address them as their imagined audience. The fragility at the heart of democracy, the fine line that once crossed separates freedom from equality or rule by the people from authoritarian demagogues are further examined through case studies of mainstream acts of journalism on the themes of immigration, urban poverty, and cultural diversity.